Wednesday, October 7, 2015

On the Sidelines: Women as Sports Fans


"I don’t think that we ask too much. We’d prefer not to be demeaned or ignored."
-Teresa Genaro, Forbes Contributor

The word "gatekeeping" is used in academic studies of gender to refer to behaviors and social norms that are done with the purpose of excluding people from a group. In sports fandom, which has been traditionally determined as a masculine activity, gatekeeping is a real and hurtful reality for women who just want to watch a football game without feeling mocked or pandered to.

The way society talks about, writes about, and markets sports are all heavily gendered and promote a culture of exclusion. Women have fought back against this by creating spaces of their own within sports fandom, including in the blogosphere and on social media. Blogging allows women to engage with sports content and interact with other sports fans while removing themselves from the sometimes toxic environment patrolled by male sports fans who don't think they belong.

Words like "accessibility" and "visibility" are at the heart of discussions surrounding how sports leagues and teams can market to women without talking down to them. With the rise of more women in high-profile sports broadcasting and management positions, it's becoming hard to ignore that women can be competent and engaged members of the sports fan community. That fact that that was ever a question is an issue in the first place.

In 2013, the Blueshirts United, the New York Rangers official fanpage, posted an article entitled "A Girl's Guide to Watching the Rangers". The article described how women, which the author assumed to be completely devoid of any sports knowledge, could learn about sports from their boyfriends without annoying them, among other offensive tips.

"Don't be afraid to ask questions, but ask questions they (the men) will enjoy answering. Things like who their favorite player is, or who their biggest rival is."

The scariest thing to note- the author of the article, which was eventually taken down due to backlash, is a woman. Gatekeeping isn't simply a male-on-female or vice versa issue, it also ties in the problems that arise from internalized misogyny. Women have been socialized to know their place, and when that place isn't in male-dominated spheres like sports, women can become hostile to others of their same gender.

One big takeaway from all of this information is that the recognition that varying levels of fandom exist outside of gender is a simple way to combat gatekeeping in sports. Sometimes fans- men and women- are content to watch without much knowledge. Sometimes they want to do data analysis. And sometimes they want to see funny Super Bowl commercials. All of these things are okay; there is no one "right way" to be a fan, and people need to remember that.

--
Bibliography

Antunovic, Dunja, and Marie Hardin. "Women Bloggers: Identity And The Conceptualization Of Sports." New Media & Society 15.8 (2013): 1374-1392. Academic Search Premier. Web.

Connors, Sarah. "While the Women Watch: A Hockey Fan Guide for Everyone." Stanley Cup of Chowder. SB Nation, 28 Jan. 2013. Web. 7 Oct. 2015.


Dicaro, Julie. "Ugly Truth about Women in Sports and Social Media." Sports Illustrated. 28 Sept. 2015. Web.

Esmonde, Katelyn, Cheryl Cooky, and David L. Andrews. "It's Supposed To Be About The Love Of The Game, Not The Love Of Aaron Rodgers' Eyes": Challenging The Exclusion Of Women's Sports Fans. " Sociology Of Sport Journal 32.1 (2015):. 22-48 Academic Search Premier. Web.

Tuesday, October 6, 2015

The Rollercoaster of Professional Women's Soccer


"Being a professional soccer player... It's probably embarrassing like how much below the poverty line we get paid." 
-Hayley Haagsma, Sky Blue FC (NWSL)

In December of 1998, the first attempt at a professional women's soccer league in the US flopped. The 1996 Olympics, where women's soccer first became a medal sport, were far gone from most soccer fans' minds, despite the success of the US team, led by legend Mia Hamm. This marked the start of a number of ups and downs for women's soccer culminating in the creation of the National Women's Soccer League (NWSL), a 9-team league founded in 2012.

Following the success of the US women's national team in the World Cup this past summer, the NWSL is set to flourish in the upcoming season. The fanbase is there, the hype is there, and the lessons learned from the failures of past leagues are in the back of everyone's minds. The question still remains- is it possible to have a successful professional women's soccer league?

The first step seems to be the support of the US Soccer Federation. Jennifer Rottenberg, who was a part of trying to create the '98 flop, the National Soccer Alliance (NSA), believes that the Federation was "hostile" to the new women's league for fear of it competing with then-new Major League Soccer (MLS). The Federation said that they were afraid of the NSA failing after one year without adequate support and hindering further progress. With that catch-22, the NSA did fail, but a women's soccer league would be attempted again in 2001. 

The second key to success for women's soccer is timing. The second attempt at a professional league, the Women's United Soccer League (WUSA), was unveiled on the heels of the 1999 World Cup, with players from multiple national teams in order to cater to as many markets as possible. The WUSA came on too strong, however, and revenue fell far below their projected earnings and high salaries. They created a product without finding a market for it, and the league folded in 2003, a little before the next World Cup was scheduled to occur.

The third and final cog in the master plan for a successful women's soccer league in the US is figuring out how to make it last. The Olympics only happen every four years, and the US isn't going to win it every time, despite their best efforts. The NWSL has branded itself as the place to watch Olympic-caliber soccer every year, and has had a modest effort in selling its product to soccer fans around the country. They have built a fanbase, and now they need to expand it.

With the continued success of the NWSL should also come increased benefits for the players, like a livable salary, better training facilities and schedules, and player sponsorships on par with what male athletes have come to expect with their professional careers. This, in turn, will lead to more exposure for the NWSL as a whole. Seems like a win-win, if you ask me.


--
Bibliography

Grange, Michael. "Women forming pro soccer league; Cashing in on popularity of 1999 World Cup." The Globe and Mail (Canada). (February 16, 2000 Wednesday ): 589 words. LexisNexis Academic. Web.

Loh, Stefanie. "Second chance; New women's soccer league planned; ." Spokesman Review (Spokane, WA). (September 5, 2007 Wednesday ): 824 words. LexisNexis Academic. Web.

Longman, Jere. "SOCCER; Women's Soccer League Folds on World Cup's Eve." The New York Times. (September 16, 2003 Tuesday ): 1165 words. LexisNexis Academic. Web. Date


Dodson, Aaron. "'Now What?' Back to Work in NWSL after Women's World Cup Thrill Ride." The Washington Post. 24 July 2015. Web.

Shipley, Amy. "U.S. Women Want Soccer to Go Pro; Others Question a League's Viability." The Washington Post. (July 9, 1999 , Friday, Sunday, Final Edition ): 1395 words. LexisNexis Academic. Web.

Shipley, Amy. "Women's League Falls Short of Goal; Sanctioning Problems, Timing Hampered Sport's Pro Development." The Washington Post. (April 17, 1998 , Friday, Final Edition ): 2484 words. LexisNexis Academic. Web.


The 99ers. Dir. Erin Leyden. Perf. Michelle Akers, Brandi Chastain, Mia Hamm. ESPN Films, 2013. Film.

The AAGPBL: A League of Their Own


"Each girl stands, her head so proudly high/Her motto 'Do or Die.'/She's not the one to use or need an alibi." 
Official Song of the All-American Girls Baseball League

The All-American Girls Professional Baseball League (AAGPBL) was founded in 1943 by Philip Wrigley, Branch Rickey, and Paul Harper in response to fears that Major League Baseball (MLB) would collapse due to the number of young players being drafted into World War II. They defined the rules, scouted and signed the players, and marketed what would become a rousing "first" in women's professional sports to current baseball fans.

The movie A League of Their Own follows the creation of the AAGPBL by chronicling the journey of Dottie Hinson, a character loosely based on Dottie Kamenshek, who was a 7-time All Star in the AAGPBL and holds the record for all time hits and total bases. The film goes through the first year of the league, with typical Hollywood dramatization, and focuses on how the lives of the players changed as they fell deeper into their baseball careers. On a more realistic note, the movie includes a segment where a Life magazine reporter is shooting a game and one of their photos propels the league into popularity- which actually happened.

Despite the opportunities afforded to these women, sexism and social norms were still highly present in the AAGPBL. Players were expected to dress and act ladylike, even when coming off the field covered in dirt from sliding into home. Teams had chaperones that went with the players on outings with male friends, and players were forbade from smoking or drinking in public. In short, they were paid to take the place of the boys, but they still were not allowed into the boys' club.

The AAGPBL was one of the first of its kind, but definitely not the last. The past few decades have seen the rise- and fall- of many professional women's sports leagues, including the Women's Pro Softball League (WPSL), which was founded in 1997 and folded in 2001. In 2004, the WPSL relaunched as National Pro Fastpitch (NPF), and currently features five teams located in major baseball markets.

For some, however, softball is not the answer to the demise of women's professional baseball. In an interview for "A Journal of Baseball History and Culture", three female baseball players who played in various semi-pro leagues across their careers said that they would pick baseball over softball if they were able to play again. "Fastpitch softball is great, but it’s not baseball!" said Sal Coats, a former Ladies League Baseball (LLB) player. The LLB is the only professional women's baseball league since the AAGPBL to last longer than a season before folding.

--
Bibliography

A League of Their Own. Dir. Penny Marshall. Perf. Geena Davis, Tom Hanks, Lori Petty. Columbia Tristar Home Video, 1992. Film.

Berman, Eliza. "Meet the Real Women Who Inspired A League of Their Own." Life 8 Apr. 2015. Web.

Nemec, David. "Leagues Of Their Own Design." Nine: A Journal Of Baseball History & Culture 21.2 (2013): 107-124.